Appellate Brief Filed with the Ohio Supreme Court Questioning the Unconstitutional Taxation of Remote Workers

Friday January 21, 2022 Published in
Supreme Court Image Canva

January 14, 2022

Jay Carson, on behalf of client The Buckeye Institute, filed a jurisdictional appellate brief with the Ohio Supreme Court raising substantial constitutional questions related to the taxation of remote workers.

In 2020, The Buckeye Institute filed suit against the City of Columbus challenging the constitutionality of taxation by local municipalities of non-residents.  The Court ruled in favor of the City of Columbus, and subsequently The Buckeye Institute appealed with the Tenth District Court of Appeals Court who affirmed the lower court’s decision.  Now the matter is before the Ohio Supreme Court.

The brief urges the Court to review the Tenth District’s decision based on the fundamental requirement of Due Process for municipal taxation and the issue of public interest.  “The Tenth District’s decision presents a substantial departure from established jurisprudence and goes so far as to indicate that the mere presence of an employer within a city’s limits may be enough of a fiscal connection for that city to tax its employees, regardless of where they work. No Ohio court has ever adopted this rule, and its 8 implications in a world where remote work is likely to become more common raise significant constitutional as well as public policy questions.”

In addition to the brief, Mr. Carson spoke with Brian Thomas of 55KRC and Matt Wright of Fox8 News.


Wegman Hessler specializes in business law for business leaders, applying legal discipline to solve business problems to help business owners run smarter. For more than 50 years, this Cleveland business law firm provides full-service strategic legal counsel for closely held businesses. Learn more at www.wegmanlaw.com.

Related Stories

The FTC Non-Compete Ban: Ways to Protect Your Business Interests


As a business leader, you’ve likely relied on non-compete agreements to safeguard your company’s confidential information, protect your investments in employee training, and maintain a competitive edge. However, with the…

Read More
FTC non compete ban

The FTC’s Non-Compete Ban: Navigating the New Reality for Business Owners


The business landscape is set to undergo a significant shift in early September with the Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC) recent comprehensive ban on new non compete agreements between employers and…

Read More
A business law attorney, David Knowles celebrates 50 years specializing in HR law with Wegman Hessler business law firm in Ohio.

Celebrating 50 years in the practice of HR law, David R. Knowles of Cleveland’s Wegman Hessler Valore still embraces the constant of change


As he drives to Wegman Hessler Valore’s Cleveland area headquarters, David R. Knowles reflects on a city that has undergone enormous transformation during his tenure there. The factories that once…

Read More